After taking down the Scarecrow in a failed attempt to retrieve the Chaos Emerald of Gotham City, Michaelangelo, Adam, Iago, Slimer, and Ed watch a scary movie that evening to relax themselves- but the nightmares it portrays on the screen soon become reality. After the four goofs finish watching it, strange, terrifying things start to happen at Angel Grove High. As our heroes disappear one by one, what could be behind it?
It's not Raven's powers going out of control making the monsters without even thinking about them. This time, it actually is Scarecrow behind the attacks.
- This episode is a fanmake to the Teen Titans episode with the same name.