This is how Umarak forces Twilight to choose goes in
Umarak the Hunter: [offscreen] Give me the Mask of Control.
[Umarak then walks over to Twilight's friends and uses his shadows on them, causing them to cry out in pain]
Twilight Sparkle: Stop! Leave them alone!
[Umarak then turns to face Twilight, waiting for her to make her decision]
Umarak the Hunter: What's it gonna be? Them or the mask?
[Twilight looks between the mask and her friends]
[Twilight then decides to save her friends]
Twilight Sparkle: No!
[Umarak then walks over to the Mask of Control]
[Umarak picks up the mask as Twilight saves her friends]
Umarak the Hunter: Excellent decision, Twilight.
[Umarak then grabs the Mask of Control. Umarak stops and turns to face Twilight]
Umarak the Hunter: [to Twilight] You care, it makes you weak. You have no chance against the darkness.
[Umarak then disappears in the shadows]
[Twilight and her friends arrive at the throne room in Canterlot]
Twilight Sparkle: [to Celestia and Luna] I'm sorry. I lost the mask.
Princess Celestia: You don't need to apologize.
Princess Luna: It's fine.
Onua: [to Twilight] But you saved your friends.
[Tahu approaches Twilight and places a hand on her shoulder]
Tahu: You did the right thing.
[Twilight looks down]
Princess Celestia: Is something wrong, Twilight?
Princess Luna: What is the matter?
Twilight Sparkle: [sighs] The hunter said caring made us weak.
Princess Celestia: No one is weak when they care, Twilight.
Princess Luna: But instead, it makes them stronger.